Representative Luis Gutierrez (D, IL) will introduce another stab at “comprehensive immigration reform” this month and it’s been given another one of those Orwellian names that you know means the opposite of what it says in the title. Gutierrez is calling this mess the Comprehensive Immigration Reform for America’s Security and Prosperity Act of 2009, or the CIR ASAP — in other words Comprehensive Immigration Reform ASAP.
The simple fact of the matter is that, regardless of the name, this legislation will do nothing whatever to help our security or our prosperity. In fact it will damage both.
In his press release touting this bill, Gutierrez said the following:
“We have waited patiently for a workable solution to our immigration crisis to be taken up by this Congress and our President,” said Rep. Gutierrez. “The time for waiting is over. This bill will be presented before Congress recesses for the holidays so that there is no excuse for inaction in the New Year. It is the product of months of collaboration with civil rights advocates, labor organizations, and members of Congress. It is an answer to too many years of pain —mothers separated from their children, workers exploited and undermined security at the border— all caused at the hands of a broken immigration system. This bill says ‘enough,’ and presents a solution to our broken system that we as a nation of immigrants can be proud of.”
This morning I spoke to Representative Brian Billbray in that nation’s capitol and found him chagrined by the whole thing. Billbray is the Chairman of the Immigration Reform Caucus and is from California’s 50th District which is situated in the San Diego County area.
Billbray told me that he was amazed that the Democrats are trying to push this thing through because we are “in the middle of a major financial downturn with unemployment over 10%.” He shook his head wondering “how crazy can we get in one move?,” referring to the many, many things this Administration and the Democrats are trying to throw at the American people all at one time. From bailouts and wild spending sprees, to Healthcare, to Afghanistan, and now to immigration “reform” how much can the country take before enough is enough?
As far as Rep. Billbray is concerned, with this bill Rep. Gutierrez is not representing the Constitution or the current voters of the U.S. but is only “vying for cheap votes and cheap labor.” He went on to say that this bill is “custom made for people breaking the law and to reward those employers who have created the problem.” He also strongly asserted that this bill will become a “magnet for more illegal immigration.”
I asked him if e-verify was addressed in this bill? E-verify is a system whereby employers can quickly and easily check if a job applicant is here legally and is legally available for work in this country. Billbray, though, told me that this new bill dismantles e-verify and goes to the absurd length to create a whole new system to replace it.
Well what it does is it starts to create a whole new other program that specifically says that instead of using e-verify they want to create an alternative program which would then give you a justification to go another 10 years trying to develop a new system rather than basically doing what *Heath Shuler’s bill does and that is adopt e-verify and move forward on what we have now rather than have to dismember e-verify starting over on a whole new program.
*Heath Shuler (D, NC)
Next I asked Rep. Billbray about the Dream Act section of Gutierrez’ bill, the part that allows illegals tuition and entrance into American colleges. Billbray was certainly incensed about this provision.
Well let me tell you something. If you want to sit there and tell people that first of all we are going to reward your children for being illegally in our country, we’re going to tell foreign nationals that play by the rules that they’ll get punished for playing by the rules, and if you’re going to tell U.S. citizens that they are going to have to stand in line behind illegal aliens when they go to college that’s just adding insult to injury.
Billbray mentioned that because they attended a Virginia High School his own children were forced to pay out-of-state tuition in California — even though they are from California and their own father is one of California’s Representatives. This status could have caused them to lose their spot in school and have to wait. Worse a student deemed a proper Californian could have taken their spot. Billbray notes that this would have included illegals in California who are eligible for in-state status thanks to the recent Martinez case in California’s Appellate Courts.
I then asked Billbray if any Republicans were signing onto Gutierrez’ bill and he said that to his knowledge none were. When asked if Republican Leader John Boehner (R, Ohio) could hold that line he said that he thought he could but said it was “sad” to see an across the board retreat on immigration law enforcement by the Democrats. Billbray said that the Democrats are accommodating the “next wave of illegal immigration” with this bill.
And he had a warning for us:
Now I want to say it bluntly; if we pass an amnesty bill like this we will not be able to build a fence tall enough to keep them from overwhelming this country. The word will get out around that world that America will reward you if you come into the United States illegally. And that is a message we can’t afford to send.
I also asked Billbray if this bill did anything to shore up construction of the border fence and he told me that it does not. What it does do, however, is try to create a “safety strategy to try to make sure the illegals don’t die coming across the border.”
Interestingly, Billbray mentioned that more people die each year trying to cross our southern border than died in the Oklahoma City bombing back in 1995. Billbray said that if Democrats wanted to prevent people from dying by crossing our border a bill like this that increases the reason people will try to come here illegally won’t help at all.
Finally I asked what would happen next with this bill. Rep. Billbray said that Gutierrez claimed that he had commitments from the Chairman that they’d be able to get hearings started on this as early as January, so this mess could come up in short order at the start of the new year.
This introduction of immigration reform is a piece with the overwhelm-them-all approach of this Administration. Obama and his radical cohorts hope that they will so fatigue the American people, that they will be so overwhelmed, they will stop paying attention to all the radical changes that the Democrats are trying to make in this country. But it is also of a piece with the ultimate goal which is to destroy our national sovereignty, dampen our economic freedom, and put us in thrall to big government. Representative Gutierrez’ efforts are just one more cog in that anti-American leviathan with which Obama is trying to run roughshod over this whole country.
Unfortunately, it is yet another big mess that we are going to have to gear up to fight if we want to save this country.
(Originally posted at RedCounty.com)



6 Responses
If Internet blogger’s, the national and rural newspaper comments, forums or bulletin boards, are a national grading of passing Comprehensive Immigration Reform–FORGET IT! IT JUST ISN’T GOING TO HAPPEN! I follow the commentaries very carefully and my observation show a very negative response to any new law that indicates giving the 20 to 30 million illegal immigrants a more or less free passport to the road of citizenship. We don’t have to forcibly deport, as E-Verify is the computer ideally suited to eject foreign labor from the all working locations? IT WORKS! It’s success rate is climbing even higher, as its continuely modified. Under normal circumstances it would be an impossibility to pass any AMNESTY? But when the headlines scream that 15 million irate Americans and legal residents cannot find employment, the chances of giving another AMNESTY, is impossible–and absolutely, incredulous that they would even try? Advancing this insane reform law under the noses of middle class Americans is going to be a expiration of Sen. Harry Reid (D-NV), Speaker Pelosi, Napolitano and a whole mis-match of Democrats who are thinking they will be re-elected. Rep. Luis Gutierrez (D-Ill.) champion of his government in Mexico and throughout Central and South America will–NOT–survive his incumbent election. No tourist or student overstays are equally unwelcome in this nation of laws. CALL ALL YOUR SENATORS AND EVEN CONGRESSMEN/ WOMEN. NOW and urge them–NOT–to support COMPREHENSIVE IMMIGRATION REFORM. IT’S NOT NEEDED? THE ! THE 1986 IMMIGRATION REFORM BILL WAS NEVER, EVER ENFORCED. The Capitol Switchboard’s telephone number is 202-224-3121. REMEMBER TO SEND IN YOUR 28Cent POSTCARDS NOW! WE MUST DEFEAT THIS IMMIGRATION REFORM PACKAGE.
There must be heavy consequences to illegally settling here, such as upgrading the unauthorized entry to a felony. In the future we must have an orderly immigration recruitment system, but only for people with highly skilled qualifications. Guest Workers must be equally vetted and not just given permission without strict–return instructions home, after completing their contract. No family reunification, because this has been rife with fraud as sponsors end up reneging on the financial aspect. All this issues can easily be resolved with amendment to the 1986 immigration bill. What to do with 20 to 30 million illegal aliens from across the world, slowly repatriate them using the SAVE ACT. We are unable to afford the costs attributed to illegal immigration. Learning in the Sanctuary State of California has collapsed from the massive surge of illegal foreign nationals into the school system.
Observe CNN TV documentary this week, “California in Crisis” The state may still implode under the huge burden of supporting financially the illegal aliens with large families. Unrevealed billions of dollars are skimmed from state treasuries, to pay for the immigrants that cannot sustain themselves around this nation. The demented politicians in Sacramento are already talking about raising taxes. No state remains untouched by the unparalleled invasion of this great sovereign country.Understand the immigration enforcement gradings of your politicians at NUMBERSUSA. Understand how taxpayers have been taken for a ride for decades and the unrevealed costs to you. See what JUDICIAL WATCH has to say about CORRUPTION in WASHINGTON. IF AMNESTY PASSES WE ARE JUST A SHORT INTERLUDE FROM OVERPOPULATION AND A THIRD WORLD COUNTRY EXISTENCE.
Posted on December 16th, 2009 at 1:05 pm
Loser Gutierrez sure has some nerve to think Americans will not be upset over another attempt at amnesty. Didn’t 2007 show him the anger of Americans on this issue? This guy has to be the most un-American politician we have, as only all things Mexican appeal to him. His plans also include gutting the 287g program as well as E-Verify. Why would we want to give criminals the highest prize of citizenship, when they break so many laws. This would include illegal entry, working when they are not entitled, ID fraud so they can work illegally, tax evasion, driving without a license or insurance, to name a few laws they feel they don’t need to abide by. We have immigration laws on the books and need no others. Enforce them frevently8 and deport those who will not abide by our rules. We have no need for millions of low-skilled, low education law breakers. Americans will make sure this bill dies, as it should because its a piece of garbage legislation.
Posted on December 16th, 2009 at 1:11 pm
Can someone tell me who will be running against that idiot Gutierrez? I would like to donate to that individuals election fund. Gutierrez needs to be put out of his misery as well as ours.
Posted on December 17th, 2009 at 12:53 am
Per the author: No Republican is running against Gutierrez. He is in a safe seat in a safe district.
Bummer. Illinois politics strikes again.
Posted on December 17th, 2009 at 12:58 pm
This a-hole Gutierrez gets away with calling Border Patrol agents “The Gestapo” on the floor of the House. And no one says “Boo!” about it. Not even the Republican lawmakers.
He’s from the Illinois Political/Organized Crime Machine. (Is that redundant?) More ignorant, uneducated people is exactly the kind of voters they love in the land of Obama.
Posted on December 17th, 2009 at 4:58 pm
This will never fly!
American are already mad a hell over the economy and unemployment. Our way of life is going down the tubes and these idiots in Washington are not listening. to us. As a lifelong Democrat, I am not ashamed to say that I will be voting for every Republican on the ballot in 2010 and 2012 as this is the only way we will get their attention,
Guttierrez can take his big barracuda teeth and sink them into someone else’s wallet!
Posted on December 29th, 2009 at 4:51 pm
Add A Comment